Which of the following is NOT one of the 10 proven things that make a difference academically and psychologically for gifted learners?

The correct answer identifies an approach that is not one of the ten proven strategies that specifically support gifted learners. Maintaining learning with age-level peers suggests a focus on ensuring that gifted students stay aligned with their peers of the same age, potentially at the expense of challenging their advanced capabilities.

Gifted learners typically benefit more from environments that provide them with the opportunity to engage with content that is rigorous and stimulating, which often involves working at a level above their current peers. This environment fosters both their academic growth and their psychological development, as it encourages them to use their advanced skills and abilities in meaningful ways.

In contrast, the other strategies, such as providing rigorous challenges, focusing on whole-to-part complexity in learning, and scaffolding independent learning skills, are foundational elements that effectively cater to the unique needs of gifted learners. These considerations promote critical thinking, deeper understanding, and the ability to independently navigate complex concepts, which are essential for their educational and social-emotional development.